The INQUIRER Network: HOME | NEWS | SHOWBIZ & STYLE | TECHNOLOGY | BUSINESS | OPINION | GLOBAL NATION
Site MapAdvertise | Buy Content | SMS Alerts | Newsletter | Archive | Contact us | About INQUIRER.net
SEARCH WEB INQUIRER Powered by: Google
Tue, Nov 24, 2009 05:15 PM, 12:00pm Philippines
About YOU | Archive | Site Map | Contact Us
Super!
2bu!
Blog Addicts
Expressions
Vid & Vibe
E-Life
Anime Culture
Republic Of Comics
Barkada Scene
Radio on Inquirer.net

 
Vid & Vibe Type Size: (+) (-)
You are here: Home > Vid & Vibe

ARTICLE SERVICES
  Print this article      Reprint this article  
  Send as an e-mail     Feedback  

RELATED STORIES



GALLERY
 

SPATIAL REASONING For a writer, space and freedom are oxygen

Advertisement


OTHER STORIES


ARTICLE SERVICES    Sponsored by: INQUIRER
  Print this article      Reprint this article  
  Send as an e-mail     Feedback  

 
THUNDER ROAD
Right to write

By James Gabrillo
Philippine Daily Inquirer

Last updated 17:50:00 06/06/2008

MANILA, Philippines—As a visual, kinetic medium, cinema isn’t particularly well suited to exploring the work of a writer—the silent ordeal of stringing together words and sentences and the mental exercise of trying to reach out from the page to interact with a reader’s thoughts and feelings. No matter how vibrant the prose, the act of writing is about as cinematic as a box of rocks.

But that hasn’t stopped filmmakers from trying, at least superficially, to depict writers’ lives. Countless films revolve around mild-mannered scribblers surrounded by insanity that must, one day, be captured on the page.

They may be caught up in adventures beyond their control, as in “Misery,” “Barton Fink,” or “Swimming Pool,” or they may be the agents of their own mayhem, as in “His Girl Friday” or “Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas.” Or they may fall somewhere in the middle, like the famous writer in “Capote” and “Infamous.”

But these movies focus on the gathering of raw material, not the writing itself. They show us the mining of clay instead of the sculpting, or they sum it up briefly with a shot of a typewritten manuscript placed confidently on an editor’s desk (the best work he’s seen in ages).

They’re not insightful about the process, but who can blame the filmmakers for avoiding the drudgery? As the writer played by Jack Nicholson in “The Shining” says—or types, repeatedly, for days—“all work and no play makes Jack a dull boy.”

“Stranger Than Fiction,” “Adaptation,” and the Danish film “Reconstruction” subject their characters to the turbulence of the writing process, directly and self-consciously, but the emphasis is not on the creator; it’s on the characters, poor souls trapped in the dim space between the ink ribbon and the page, suffering the whims of an omniscient wordsmith.

Movies like “Memento” have such aggressively unconventional story structures that they can’t accurately be called literary—they’re pure cinema—but the best of them clearly draw ideas from written fiction: The heavily symbolic screenplay for “Hiroshima Mon Amour” was written by a novelist, Marguerite Duras, and “Pulp Fiction’s” very title reveals its origins.

When the space tightens

My favorite film about writing is Chantal Akerman’s “The Man With the Suitcase,” though I’ve only seen it once. It’s about a woman who borrows a friend’s apartment to write, unaware that someone else will be using the apartment—a man who arrives with a suitcase and who, by all appearances, intends to be there for a while.

On paper, it’s fodder for sitcoms or pulpy movies like the aforementioned “Swimming Pool.” But Akerman has a long-running obsession with personal space, especially the way it relates to a person’s identity, and her ideas are especially fitting in this context.

I’ve heard the film called a comedy, but it doesn’t seem funny when the woman stops working and holes up in her room, hiding from the man, listening to his every move, monitoring his comings and goings so she can sneak out for a breath of fresh air or a trip to the shower or the kitchen.

Seldom do we see her working, and, yet, unlike many movies about writers who never write, this one is aware that the situation is choking her.

Film critic Anthony Lane has said that writing ought to be wedged into real life; that writers are probably at their best when made to huddle in stairwells.

Maybe so, but for some of us that’s an existence on the edge, dangerously close to not writing at all, not breathing at all.

Lights, camera, action

Akerman’s story clearly has a feminist undercurrent—the man who goes about his life, cooking, shaving, and working, is barely aware of the woman who bends, who crumbles, to accommodate his presence—but it’s also a painfully true look at the life of a writer for whom space and freedom are oxygen.

At the end, the man takes his suitcase and leaves for good, the film closing with the joyous sound of a typewriter and a shot of the woman—played by Akerman herself—working.

Working! I’m not sure if the end marks Akerman as an optimist or simply a realist, but either way it’s a release. The conditions have arisen, miraculously, that allow the writer to write.

Sadly, “The Man With the Suitcase” isn’t available on DVD, and it’s rarely screened anywhere in the world because no one has bothered to subtitle the French dialogue. When I saw it at the Escuela de cine de Barcelona, a student assistant read a Spanish translation into a microphone to help us understand the film’s few words. So this movie about the fleeting moments that writers crave is itself hanging in a muffled state of hesitation.

Nevertheless, it’s locked in my brain, and I should be sleeping instead of writing, so now I’m off to bed to dream a movie-dream and, with any luck, write again tomorrow.

     


  ^ Back to top

© Copyright 2001-2009 INQUIRER.net, An INQUIRER Company

The INQUIRER Network: HOME | NEWS | SHOWBIZ & STYLE | TECHNOLOGY | BUSINESS | OPINION | GLOBAL NATION | Site Map
Services: Advertise | Buy Content | Wireless | Newsletter | Low Graphics | Search | Archive | Contact us
The INQUIRER Company: About the Inquirer | User Agreement | Link Policy | Privacy Policy



Advertisement

Inquirer VDO

Property Guide

BizLinq

Inquirer Blogs